GeekSays

Latest Technology News & Geeky Gadgets

  • All News
  • Apple
  • Jailbreak News
  • How To
  • Recommends
  • About GeekSays
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Terms And Privacy
  • March 30, 2023
You are here: GeekSays Technology News » General » Blogger Fined For Restaurant Review That Ranked High In Google

Blogger Fined For Restaurant Review That Ranked High In Google

Last updated on July 22, 2014 By Keelan Balderson Leave a Comment

Blogger Fined For Restaurant Review That Ranked High In Google

In what may create a controversial precedent a French blogger has been fined by the courts because her negative restaurant review just happened to appear near the top of Google search.

Caroline Doudet who visited the Il Giardino restaurant last Summer was fined €1,500 in damages and forced to pay a further €1,000 to cover court costs. Her crime was simply blogging that she experienced poor service and a bad attitude from the owner, during her visit to the Aquitaine region of southwestern France last August. The key factor however was that her review appeared fourth in Google search for the name of the establishment.


Unrelated image

The owner sued Doudet claiming the blog unfairly hurt her business, and the judge agreed. Not only was Doudet fined, but was forced to re-title the post which was published as “the place to avoid in Cap-Ferret: Il Giardino”.

Furthermore the judge issued an emergency order, which Doudet says left her unable to find legal representation for the hearing. In essence she was shut down before even being able to defend herself.

In light of the situation Doudet has since voluntarily removed the post altogether.

This case is worrying on a number of fronts for webmasters and bloggers. Not only does it completely ignore a basic right to free speech, but it also suggests that simply being popular means you have less rights to voice that speech.

Even more concerning is the judge’s apparent ignorance of the way search engines operate. Doudet did not choose for her post to appear prominently in Google. While she could have potentially implemented some Search Engine Optimization (SEO) techniques, it is Google itself, a completely separate entity that selects what content to include in its index.

If I told a group of friends at a gathering that I hate Nike trainers, then one of them erected a billboard in the high street quoting me, am I responsible for that billboard?

Of course going after a giant corporation like Google is not as easy as applying ambiguous aspects of the law to a lone citizen.

While Doudet might not blog as a source of income, many bloggers do. In similar circumstances the very thing which the judge was trying to protect – the livelihood of the restaurant owner – could just as easily effect the livelihood of the blogger.

In the blogger’s case this is quantifiable. Remove a post and eventually those hits go away. In the restaurant owner’s situation one has to wonder how they measured the blogger’s impact. How can you prove that a blog harmed business?

At the crux of this story is a fear of negative press. The restaurant owner was so concerned about negative press they went on the offensive. The ironic thing is the restaurant and their heavy handed tactics have now received much wider coverage than ever could have been imagined previously. It backfired.

The whole situation has been a complete waste of everybody’s time, and leaves other bloggers open to frivolous lawsuits in the future.

Is this another example of the benefits of the Google service right to be forgotten? Let us know your thoughts below.

Filed Under: General, Google

About Keelan Balderson

Keelan Balderson is a Blogger, Youtuber and Podcaster from the UK, with an avid interest in technology, alternative politics, and pro wrestling.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Stay Updated

Become GeekSays exclusive subscriber and get all the spice directly in your mail.

Stay Connected

Editor’s Choice

iPhone 7 A1660/A1661 Qualcomm Modem vs A1778/A1784 Intel Modem

February 28, 2017 By Hamza Sheikh Leave a Comment

How to Watch Live TV on Your iPhone Using Channels Without Jailbreak

February 13, 2017 By Hamza Sheikh Leave a Comment

Best VPN Apps for iPhone/iPad to Unblock School Wifi Restrictions

February 9, 2017 By Hamza Sheikh 2 Comments

Apple iPhone 7 Plus A1661 SIM-Free Review

February 6, 2017 By Hamza Sheikh 1 Comment

Difference Between iPhone 7 Models: A1660, A1778, and A1779 (Detailed)

January 23, 2017 By Hamza Sheikh Leave a Comment

Technology News & Geeky Gadgets

GeekSays is a technology news and geeky gadgets blog / community, dedicated to the latest technology news and gadgets from all over the tech industry. GeekSays focuses on the upcoming latest technology scoops about iPhone, Apple, Samsung, Google, Android, Microsoft, Windows, BlackBerry, and the latest geeky tech gadgets. GeekSays plays an important role in breaking technology updates about upcoming events, tech devices, features, gadgets and verdicts from all the mainstream technology companies. It also covers tutorials on how to use the iphone, reviews of best android apps, iOS downloads,..

Copyright © 2023 Geek Says | All Rights Reserved